Andrea Lynn Piazza

The Many Parts of Being a Woman

With Holly Wigmore, therapist, queer- and trans-affirming, IFS-certified candidate. Hosted by Andrea Lynn Piazza and Katie Roletto.

Listen on SpotifyApple PodcastsRead the transcript
About this episode

Therapist Holly Wigmore — a queer- and trans-affirming counselor and IFS-certified candidate practicing in Oregon and California — joins Andrea and Katie for a wide-ranging conversation on what it actually means to be a woman in the therapy room, as both patient and provider. They unpack intersectionality, why so many clients specifically seek out women therapists, the historical baggage of certain diagnoses, the quiet suffering of men under masculinity's weight, and how Internal Family Systems ("parts") work helps people hold their own multitudes. Plus a hard look at high-functioning anxiety — the kind that gets praised as competence — and Holly's parting line you'll want to write down: stop equating your worth with how much you can tolerate.

“Stop equating your worth with how much you can tolerate.”
From this episode
Free: take it with you

Questions from this episode

  1. Where am I praised for handling things that are actually too much?
  2. What part of me is doing most of the work right now?
  3. What would I tolerate less of if my worth weren't tied to it?
  4. Who gets to see the struggling version of me?

Answer them on paper or in your notes app. Nothing here is saved or sent anywhere.

Free toolFunctioning, or performing it?For high-functioning anxiety and burnout that hides well.Open →
Related reading
Parts work and IFS, plainly

More free tools: resources · Newsletter: Andrea and Other Frustrated People

Transcript

Full episode transcript

An automatic transcript, lightly edited. Speakers aren't labeled. About 5000 words.

Read the transcript

0:19Welcome to What Your Therapist Really Thinks. We need to talk about the good, the bad, and the ugly of what mental health professionals face every day. I'm Andrea Piazza, and... Oh, I'm Katie Maletto. And today we have an incredible guest. We are talking about mental health and women. We have Holly Wigmore on today. Holly is a professional counselor in the state of Oregon and California. She is also a level one IFS therapist and is an IFSI certified candidate, which is an incredible accomplishment for anybody who doesn't know. IFS is very hard. It's very hard even to get into the training, so the fact that she's on this path is really, really cool. Welcome, Holly. What a nice compliment to be welcomed to.

1:00That's so nice. We're so excited to talk about this subject. I think it's important as we talk about this that gender is one dimension of identity. I think that how much you identify the importance of being a woman or not being a woman is culturally dependent and depends individual to individual. I think it's really important to talk about, when we talk about women, and that there does become another level to this of gender identification is obviously a huge spectrum. So to talk about this generally isn't going to be a full conversation. There's definitely layers to it. I think most often when we're saying women and mental health, we are referring to people who were socialized as women, almost regardless of if they transitioned to a different gender, whether that be male or somewhere in the middle or some sort of fluidity.

1:51But I think those biases are present when there's femininity at play at all. I think even men who are gay are, first of all, more likely to go to therapy, but are also more likely to be pathologized because there's an association of them with femininity that's not fair, that's not earned, but is being placed upon them. And it definitely shows up in the counseling space. I think it shows up in who can access care, the sort of diagnoses that your provider's going to think of first when they're working with you or when you walk in that room. For you, Holly, could you tell us a little bit about your population focuses? Like, who do you spend the most time talking to? Yeah. Who do you feel the most time specialized with?

2:34So I specialize in queer and trans care, and so it's really top of mind for me. Yeah, makes sense. And I also, predominantly, the people I see are women. Predominantly, I am sought out by women, queer folks, trans folks, for my identity as a woman. And so, yeah, those are the main populations I work with. And Andy, some of what you were saying is interesting to me. What you're making me think about the entanglement that a person has or doesn't have with their respective culture and with the way that respective culture sees gender and, like, does that match? Because for me, I am a cis woman. I had pressures on me, certainly growing up around being a woman. I'm a lady wearing eyeliner, right? I've got some dangly earrings on.

3:26Like, the feminine presentation for me is something that I am comfortable with and is congruent with my experience. It's just such a wide spectrum for women. Yeah, absolutely. And it's hard to have this conversation without bringing in, like, our fancy word of the day, intersectionality. So, like, we're never just a woman. We're never just a person who's in their 30s or has a specific cultural background, Hispanic, right? We're always a Hispanic woman in our 30s or an American-Italian woman in her 30s who's cisgender and, you know, sexuality tends towards men, right? And those are all different layers that, because we're all pattern recognition machines, for better or for worse, get placed on us and we place on others in order to, like, figure out our judgment if we feel safe quick enough.

4:16But it certainly shows up in the counseling space.

4:29I would say I see them presenting or they want a female or woman provider the most often. And then other times they come in and they want a male provider. We do have providers who specialize in queer care, trans care, me being one of them. And they typically are coming in wanting a female provider or provider with a queer identity, not necessarily trans or anything beyond cis. But it is one of the key things I think people look for in terms of finding somebody they're going to feel safe with and who they think is going to understand and be able to help them. And it makes sense, right? If you're a trans person and you want to see, you don't want to see someone who's stuck in that narrative. It's like, I want some sort of defining characteristic that tells me you have the lived experience of having to consider your gender and how you're treated in the world and how you're seen.

5:19That was going to be my question that I feel like you just answered, Holly, is the why of it all. You know, I find it interesting that the queer community is interested in women and actually okay with like a cis women therapist or counselor. And it is because of that, having to justify your identity in a world that is not made for us. It is not made to run for us. We are having to adapt to a cis male world. Katie, I want to ask you a slightly invasive question. I can't wait. To not answer. It's really not that bad. I'm hyping it up for what it is. When you, as a therapy goer who is not a therapist yourself, you know, look for the right person to talk to about your problems or get some mental health support, what role does gender or sort of those like layers of identity play in your selection or who you reach out to?

6:11I love that question, Andy. I think for me, I'm also kind of an open-minded person. I've had a few therapists, you guys. I've had a few of them and one was about my age, one was older, and one was a mystery voice on the other side of the phone that Kaiser put me through too. Therapy Goldilocks? Yes, a therapy Goldilocks. And so it's interesting because as I'm on my LA Care journey, as you all know, to find a therapist that takes LA Care, I am now more open. And I'm just more open. Whatever you got, you know, LA Care, whatever you got is fine as long as you can manage my anxiety. Do your worst. Do your worst. And it is interesting because now that I've, you know, I've been in therapy for about seven years is, and don't forget about Chet GPT is my therapist at the moment, who is, I think, not gender identifying.

7:04But anyway, I... What's your, what do you really think?

7:10What persona is it adopted for you? Yes. That's a different episode. What do you want me to be? Yeah, what do you want me to be? Yeah. So I, so anyway, I feel like I've had my, my buffet of therapists that I wouldn't be, I wouldn't be closed off to a male therapist. I'm going to make an improv. I can't wait. An improv example, if you will. So in an improv scene, a typical scene is there is someone who's the unusual person who does something kind of wacky, and that's where the comedy comes from. And then you have someone called a voice of reason. And that contrast to that wacky person is what heightens the funny thing. And the voice of reason person, they're just supposed to sort of be the everyday world and almost like the perspective of the audience to be like, this is weird.

7:55This is weird. This is weird. And I have found playing a voice of reason for women can be very difficult because you have to call out, this is weird that you're doing this. And that is not a thing that most, I'm going to say women, but I would just say anyone who's had an experience where they feel like they need to sort of mask a feeling of being presentable and being agreeable and being kind because you're afraid of getting hurt or you're afraid of being yelled at or afraid of being wrong. Because God forbid we're wrong.

8:29And I had a female improv coach say, what you have to do is go into your mind and say, what do you really want to say? What would you actually want to say in this moment? And you have to really do a little bit more work to get past that mask. I've been telling my male improvising coaches this thing, and they just don't clock it. So that makes me think there are just some experiences I just don't think men can understand all the time. I know a lot of men work really hard to understand it, and I think there's a lot of wonderful men out there that are really trying, but I just don't know if you can in a setting where there is that I need you to emotionally deeply understand what I'm saying. But I don't know.

9:08Prove me wrong. I don't know.

9:10I think it goes both ways, too. I work with a lot of male patients, the whole spectrum, trans men, male presenting, certainly queer patients as well, but with a lot of men, in addition to all my other beautiful humans who get to sit on the other side of the laptop with me. And there's also elements of that experience that I really have to go the extra mile to try and be on that side with them and get it. Or, you know, you just can't. Like, the pressures men are under are unbelievable and so, so toxic and scary. I think what you're saying is true. I think it's true on the other side. I think we all have our limitations, but I think in the effort to do our best and continuing to learn, that's the most we can ask for.

9:52What this conversation is bringing up is, like, when people are looking for a therapist, God, is it a daunting process. Some people just are holding on to, like, one thread, right, where it's like, are you going to get my experience? And Katie, this is a really good example of, like, this very unofficial experiment you're doing of, like, polling improv coaches of, like, there's a way that a female improviser understands what you're talking about, where your male improviser is like, I don't know if that really makes sense to me. What I love is that I did is I likened someone who had to go to grad school, get licenses, to an improv coach who, at best, maybe took a couple classes at UCB. Well, Katie, both apply to me, so don't worry about it.

10:42Yeah. No, but it is interesting because I see the sort of processing of, like, yeah, yeah, no, I don't understand. And I'm like, no, you went left. We're going right. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. And I want to march in here and bring up, because Andy started to bring it up, Katie's brought it up a little bit, but I say this all the time, that my cishet men are truly suffering. Yes. Like, truly suffering. I mean, you just look at the death by suicide rates. They're so socialized to figure it out themselves, not have a problem, be okay, not cry, right? Those are, and I'm curious, Andy, is that, like, something that you experience, too, with your patients? I think they're struggling. I think men are more comfortable coming to therapy than they used to be, even in, like, um...

11:33I think that's true, too. Yeah, even in, like, the past six years. I think post-COVID, more guys are about it, or maybe just, like, desperate enough to have to listen to me for a little bit each week. I think there's a lot of pressure, and I think there's almost, like, people go one really hard direction with it or the other. I have a lot of men who come in, and, like, they're trying to take the blame for everything. They don't want to put, maybe, any accountability on their partner, because they feel they must be all of the problem. And then it's like, okay, well, we need to have, like, a couple's conversation, because, like, it can't all just be you all the time. Or it's like, I can't be the problem at all, so I'm not coming to therapy.

12:13I think it's hard for them to find that balance, but just, like, everyone else, they're looking for connection and understanding and to just be okay and be good enough. And, yeah, that's just, like, the human condition right now. Yeah, I think it's just fair to say that it's all different experiences, and it's okay that they are different experiences. I think sometimes some of my male friends have almost been offended when I'm kind of like, well, you just don't understand. And it's like, no, it's okay. It's okay, you don't understand. Why would you understand? It's not a criticism of you. It's not that you're a bad person or you're not trying. It's we all have limitations. Yeah, absolutely. Looking at society as having parts, that there is a part of society, part of masculine identity that's, like, very, very old and really can be very harmful.

13:03I think that there are wonderful gifts to masculinity and being a man. And then there's also a lot of harm that can also come with that. And so when I'm talking about seeing my men suffering, I'm talking about my men, what? No. My male identifying clients suffering. I'm talking about their entanglement with that sort of oppressive system, even though they are seemingly at the top of that pyramid. Like, even though they're at the top of that pyramid, they're the ones suffering the most because they have to be this thing that is unattainable. Yeah, yeah. I think it also is, like, I don't know. Sometimes they don't feel deserving or valid in the help because, like, they are at the top of that food chain.

13:49That's, of course, never the words they would put it in. But it's, like, I should be the one that's okay and I'm not. Like, what's the deep, deep thing wrong with me? You guys, I just had a realization. Are men the millennials of our society? Because I feel like millennials, like, we were told that we had all these promises in the world and the world was our oyster and we were going to have our own house and we were going to have all these things. And we didn't, you know? And I think that, you know, stick with me. And men, I feel like a lot of them, like, feel like they're like, I'm supposed to be. And they're like, why am I not given all the things that I have been offered in the world? Even though there are a lot of men who are, a lot of millennials also have houses and I'm just not one of them.

14:33Well, piggybacking off of this, too, I just want to coyly note that we as women, three women sitting in a Zoom room, all just started talking about men. Like, we got. Yes! Because we were like, we can't talk about the women. We can't ignore the men. We didn't test it. We're going to do the sextile tests. We're not.

14:55Oh, no. All right, back to women, then. Turn the ship around. We're going to do another episode. Okay, here's what I actually really, really want to talk about. I don't know. Actually, can I be honest? I don't know how to talk about trans women and their pressures and how their experience is different. To be honest, I don't really know how to talk about that because I identify a lot of my societal pressures from growing up being perceived as female. So it's a bit of a different experience because I just want to make sure I'm talking about this conversation in a way that is inclusive. Yeah, I think we should be inclusive. I think there also might be something really special about giving them wholly their own episode.

15:35And maybe we just talk about female presenting people right now and then we can talk specifically about the trans woman experience, trans woman mental health in another episode because it's so deserving of its own conversation. But I do think it's such a hard conversation because we don't want to hurt anybody's feelings. We don't want anybody to be left out. We want to include everybody. But then that kind of perpetuates the issue of we never actually get to the women. Like we never actually have that data set or that focus. It's such a it's such a push pull. Part of why I love parts work so much, because I think it helps at least me to like talk about and identify an experience that can be both specific and universal.

16:21And so Katie, for your question, like I do think that there and I can't speak for everyone, but like there is right a part of being a femme identifying that like is felt whether you were socialized as a as a girl growing up or whether you're just jumping into it in your 20s. Right. Those pressures are are still like real and there and like experienced among like all of us. Yeah. Yeah, definitely. I just kind of want to make sure that we have that caveat there that it is that there is a spectrum. But I do want to talk about historically, you know, mental health has not been kind to women and it's been dismissed or pathologized. Why do you think that shift has happened? And but I would also like to talk about what was life like for women seeking mental health in the in the earlier days?

17:22What is it? What's kind of like a bad view? Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you, Holly. Yeah.

17:29Extremely, extremely bad. So, yes, I think like the most iconic example is like women always being diagnosed with hysteria, which is, you know, this kind of deep melancholy craziness. Like anytime they misbehaved, they could be labeled as somebody who was hysterical. Or if they come to you and they say, like, I'm so sad, I'm so worried about things, I can't control it. Well, you have hysteria. You know, there's this big bad thing wrong with you. I think there was somewhat of a goal of men, you know, the most famous OG psychologists are men because they were doctors and blah, blah, blah. And only men can be doctors. But their goal was to kind of fix women. And I think it kind of ultimately worked against them to where women were like, ah, well, therapy is for us then.

18:17And sort of took it and then more and more women got into the field. It's, you know, primarily women are therapists, not to say there aren't a ton of great male therapists there are, you know, and then women are more comfortable going to women. And women were the ones that told therapy was for them. And now they, you know, kind of own that space. Backfired a little bit on the boys. Is that really what happened is that it was almost like it's almost like a threat against women. And I have stories in my family of women that we were like, oh, wow, like when we were younger, like, oh, wow, yeah, she went to the, she went to the mental hospital. Wow, she might have been nuts. And then I grew up and I was like, wait, wait.

18:55Yeah. I mean, it was used to take women away from their children. It was used to, yeah, get them out of the house so you could be a move in with your mistress. Like, yeah, it was absolutely used as a punishment or as a way to control, you know, people who couldn't be as smart as the men were and must need to be fixed. I feel like we really took that space back. I do think it's interesting, too, to look at kind of like modern counseling and the way that there's this intersection of counseling, psychology and social work. Social work, which is founded by a woman. I'll speak for myself that it's kind of a, can I cuss on this? Yeah. That's so good. I'll speak for myself that it's kind of a mindfuck to, I did, I did.

19:40Cut it out. Mindfuck.

19:42But it's kind of a mindfuck to work as a counselor today where you're like sitting in between like trying to be non-pathologizing but also being like, look, I'm billing your insurance so we do have to identify a diagnosis. Something's got to be wrong, yeah. And how are we measuring you getting better except for the human experiences like deeply complex and ongoing, right? And so I think that that's also just like true. I'm noticing it even in this conversation around gender, right? Where we're like hopping between like, oh, no, like we want to make sure this is an expansive conversation. And also there's some very specific experiences we have, right? It's a mindfuck. Yes. And I want to kind of tack on here another piece that I think is important is most diagnoses, you know, all of the first bunch of diagnoses that went into the big book of things that can be wrong with your brain called the DSM were based on male data sets.

20:38And men were, white men specifically, were the norm. Like this is what it's like to behave normally. It's a white man, as Schmidt would say. So anything off of that, there was something wrong with you that you could therefore or should therefore go get therapy for. And even though that default set of data is old, it's still the default today, with the exception of certain disorders that really are daughters of hysteria, unfortunately, and are predominantly assigned to women like borderline personality disorder. And that's very stigmatized disorder. And I, for a time in my practice, I worked with BPD a lot. The thing I found myself saying over and over again to clients in session is, I think that BPD is the least interesting thing about you.

21:28I really do. Because so often when people are diagnosed with that disorder, and it's predominantly women, it's like it becomes like they've been labeled. It's so origins and drama, right? Yeah. And that is getting ignored and being told like, this is who you are. Your personality is sick. Which is just wild that like, that's still how we're dealing with things. It's still how we're talking about it. Medieval. Feels very medieval, right? And it's like the update on hysteria, right? Like, what's another way that we can identify a woman being too much? Yeah. Don't even get me started on the BMI index, girls. Don't even get me started. Invented by a mathematician, not for health reasons. When we have a dietitian or an eating disorder specialist on here, I'm going to go crazy on that.

22:18I can't wait. And they better come prepared. Oh, they'll be, they'll love it. Yeah. They're my people. I mean, it is kind of a beautiful thing that this thing that has been used to be weaponized against women has now been taken back. And obviously that there's still more work to be done, especially in the realm of diagnoses and how they still stem from these really unfair practices. Even things like postpartum depression, you know, that, you know, is like just now becoming a common thing. Perimenopause is now a hot topic, girls. Finally. No one's ever talked about that before. And now my Instagram is nothing but do you have perimenopause? I know. I can't wait. It hasn't found me yet, but I'm heading there to get later and later in my thirties.

23:04If your phone's near you, it's listening and it will. It's coming your way.

23:08I'm wondering, Holly, if there is sort of a, like a hot take that you have on, if there's something that you just wish women knew more about how, about how to take care of their mental health or when they're pursuing mental health that you wish that they knew more. Yeah, I think the thing that's bubbling up for me is just how expansive we are as individual people. Again, I shout out IFS. Parts allow us to see that a person is multidimensional, right? And I think that women are also multidimensional. If you were to ask me, like, what I think would help your mental health and your relationships, it's allowing yourself to be multifaceted and allowing other people to be multifaceted as well. Because I think that when we are constricted and feel like we can't be our whole selves or our partners can't be their whole selves because we're constricting the view of how we see them, that we're like really limiting our capacity to connect more deeply.

24:21Yeah, and I think that goes really well into the conversation of gender being a spectrum as well, that it is a conversation that we are individuals and we are complex individuals. I would love for you really quick, Holly, too, to talk a little bit about if people haven't heard of when you say parts, if you could kind of talk about that a little bit. Yeah, absolutely. So when I'm talking about parts, so internal family systems is a intervention that instead of seeing a person as sort of like mono minded or singular minded, seeing them as a multitude of parts that exist. And the way that it happens sort of really organically is you'll hear someone say, well, part of me feels this way, but part of me feels that way.

25:11And so you can see parts in lots of places in psychology, like you can see it in DBT with sort of this both and idea. It's it's a way of viewing people as a system and that that system also can be like you can use that system to view the family system of like the relationship between the three of us, the relationship with your family, the relationship to the society at large. I also guess I should name I clearly came from an MFT program if that hasn't been spoiled already. I was going to say clearly MFT. Yes, I'm just like system, system, system. I don't know what MFT means, but yes. Yes. Marriage. It's like the marriage couple family. Got you. Marriage family. Yeah. OK, yes. Yeah. Great. Yeah. No, I think that's really that's really helpful to know.

26:00And I think that that's really valuable to to talking about this conversation. Is there anything either of you would like to say to kind of chat on this conversation? I know that there I feel like we could do a part to a part. Was I too much? No.

26:15Lock her up. Yeah. I would say some buttons I'd love to put on this very fun, very vulnerable conversation would be high functioning anxiety, which we didn't talk about directly. But high functioning anxiety is often praised in women because it looks like competence. But that doesn't mean it's something you shouldn't get help with. And if I could tell, you know, our lovely listeners, especially our fem presenting women ones, whoever you may be out there to stop doing anything. Not that I want to tell you what to do. But if I could tell you to stop doing one thing, it would be stop equating your worth with how much you can tolerate. I'm working on this myself. Let me be clear. Andy, put that on a pillow.

26:57Yeah, but that's what I would wanted to toss at us. Okay. And is it time to cue Kenny? It is time to cue Kenny. All right. Thank you so much for joining us, Holly. Thank you as always, Andy. And thank you to the LA Fire Department that did not have to come to Andy's building, even though her alarm has been going off for the past few days. All right. Roll Kenny. Bye.

_Theme song by Kenny Gray._

This podcast is educational and isn't therapy or medical advice. If you're in crisis in the US, call or text 988.